Tag: british whodunnit

Ludwig

Published on by cinemadilemmaLeave a comment
https://www.radiotimes.com/

Rating: 4.5 stars out of 5
Starring: Dave Mitchell, Anna Maxwell Martin, Dipo Ola, Sophie Willan, Dorothy Atkinson, Ralph Ineson
Where to watch: BBC One
To watch or not to watch: Ooo… this is a fun watch. It is a comic-mystery and it is so much fun!!!

John Taylor (Dave Mitchell) is a master puzzle maker who lives in his childhood home, has a specific routine that needs to be followed (similar to Sheldon Cooper), has no close friends and has been estranged from his twin brother and his family for a few years now. His twin brother is named James Taylor, who is a successful DCI with Cambridge constabulary, is married to Lucy (Anna Maxwell Martin) and has a teenage son. Lucy, John and James used to be friends since they were 5 years old, and it is hinted that John had a crush on Lucy. Anyway, background now complete, James has disappeared without a conspicuous trace, and Lucy enlists John’s help – in that she wants John to impersonate his brother at the constabulary and find out what happened to him. A highly reluctant John does as he is told (he is a stickler for rules) but soon finds out entwined in regular police work, aka a murder mystery, which he finds out to be quite similar to solving puzzles which he incidentally thoroughly enjoys. With this is the overarching mystery of disappearance of his brother.

It is difficult to choose from where to begin singing praises about this series. David Mitchell and this role is a match custom made in Olympus (if Gods were flawless entities). He brings the totally-social-inept-and-out-of-depth character to fore most adequately. That in addition to what the God gave him – a highly expressive face, a physique to complement this character and the over-all look, and this makes it one of the best actor-character matches. The writing is also top notch, the script used puzzle solving into play which is a newish twist to this genre. Anna Maxwell is good too, but somehow she fails to convey the worry of a wife with a missing husband. But her character Lucy is an inspiration – she is a force of nature who would do what is necessary to figure out the disappearance and not be a despondent figure looking for a knight. The British know how to write a strong female character right.

There are plenty of comic-mystery series out there. What sets Ludwig apart is the clever writing. The puzzle solving aspect of it brings out the sleuth in all of us. Comparing the tools of the trade – DMV or arrest records, which are not usually accessible to common public, versus a puzzle which are accessible to people (might also interest some of the people) and it is not geographically limiting. Makes the series interesting in the mystery and the solving modus operandi. Not to mention the comedy sprinkled through the series coming mostly from Mitchell’s character and his social ineptness. It is rarely done this accurately. All in all, a must watch and still holds for repeat viewing.

Magpie Murders

Published on by cinemadilemmaLeave a comment
https://www.rottentomatoes.com/

Rating: 4.5 stars out of 5
Starring: Lesley Manville, Tim McMullan, Alexandros Logothetis, Conleth Hill
Where to watch: Sony Liv
Seasons and episodes: 1 season, 6 episodes 45 minutes each
To watch or not to watch: A unique plot and investigation of a murder. Absolutely a must watch

Alan Conway (Conleth Hill) is a writer of the famous Atticus Pund novels and is writing a much-awaited book in the series (think Sherlock Holmes meets Hercule Poirot style murder mystery detective). Susan Ryeland (Lesley Manville) is a London editor for Alan, and doesn’t get along with him – mainly because Alan is an irascible man who is not happy writing Atticus Pund and punishes everyone around him for his unhappiness. Susan receives the latest Atticus Pund book, titled Magpie Murders, but it is missing the last chapter where the murder in the book is solved. Susan then goes to meet Alan to get the chapter, and finds that Alan has been murdered. Also, the last chapter is nowhere to be found. She then talks to everyone who was associated with Alan and slowly uncovers the real identities of the people Alan had used as characters in his book, and people had grudges against him for one reason or another. The suspect pool grows bigger.

The series is depicted through the parallels between the case in the book and real life murder of Alan Conway. While Susan is the real detective in real life, she is often thinking like Atticus Pund, to the extend that she hallucinates him. And since the people in the book are same as those in the vicinity of the murder victim, this whole depiction can be understood even with the chasm of the timelines.

The fact that the detective in the series is an editor, not someone who is qualified to find criminals makes the detection even more interesting for the viewers – it makes it more relatable. She is sure that the solution to the murder in the book will help with the murder of the author in real life, and she needs to solve both. Although the series is across timelines with frequent jumps from one timeline to another, it gets confusing only once through the entire length of 6 episodes. It keeps the interest going, not to mention refreshing. Lesley Manville is a very unlikely detective, she is a perfect editor and this goes with the vibe of the series. Highly recommend to watch.